How is a leaking standing valve displayed on a surface dynamometer
card, a pump card and a traveling/standing valve test?
The surface card is predominately used to display surface polished
rod loads for the analysis of pumping unit beam loadings, rod loadings
and gearbox loadings. The performance of a downhole leaking standing
valve can be best displayed and analyzed on the pump card and on a
traveling/standing valve test.
The surface polished rods loads and position/velocity data are used
to calculate a pump card that can be visually inspected to determine
standing valve performance. The pump card is a valuable tool to analyze
downhole pump performance. When the plunger starts up and the traveling
valve and plunger are operating properly, the load on the plunger will
increase rapidly to the level labeled "A" in the diagram.
During normal pump operation, the load on the plunger increases until
the load is sufficient to lift the liquid to the surface. During the
upstroke, liquid is lifted to the surface. When the plunger rises in
the pump barrel, liquid and/or gas will be drawn into the pump barrel
above the standing valve. When the traveling valve starts down, the
traveling valve will remain closed until the fluid below the plunger is
pressurized to a pressure in excess of the pressure above the plunger,
which causes the traveling valve to open. As the fluid below the
traveling valve is compressed, the fluid load on the plunger decreases
rapidly if the standing valve holds to the level indicated
"C" on the diagram.. When the plunger is near the top and
bottom of the stroke, the plunger speed is lowest. If the standing
valve leaks at a moderate rate, the leakage will cause the load on the
plunger near the top and the bottom of the stroke to be greater than
the load at "C". Thus, the bottom of the pump card will be
rounded (sections B and D) when the standing valve leaks at a moderate
rate. A high rate of standing valve leakage in excess of the pump
capacity will prevent the pump from producing any liquid. Following is
an example of a pump card showing a leaking standing valve along with
the corresponding surface card.

During the standing valve test, the polished rod is stopped on the
downstroke. When the plunger enters the liquid in the pump, the
traveling valve will be open and the rod string will be partially
supported by the liquid in the tubing. If the standing valve does not
leak, the load on the polished rod will remain equal to the buoyant rod
weight. If the standing valve leaks, the fluid load will be transferred
to the traveling valve causing the polished rod load to increase. If
the standing valve leaks at a high rate, the standing valve load will
be measured to be the buoyant rod weight plus the fluid load as
displayed below.

A standing valve test that indicates leakage invalidates the
traveling valve leakage rate test. The traveling valve test is
difficult to interpret when the standing valve leaks.